South Philly Pizza

South Philly Pizza in New Philadelphia, OH, is a true haven for pizza lovers craving authentic flavors and hearty comfort food. Specializing in classic American-style pizza, this vibrant pizzeria offers an irresistible menu that keeps locals and visitors coming back for more. From their signature Pepperoni Pizza with Extra Cheese and Peppers to their fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza, each pie boasts a perfect balance of a crunchy, golden crust and a rich, sweet sauce that melts delightfully with every bite.

What truly sets South Philly Pizza apart is the careful attention to each ingredient and the craft behind each dish. The pepperoni is generously layered, releasing savory notes that complement the buttery, cheesy crust, while the Buffalo Chicken topping offers a spicy kick that excites the palate. Alongside the pizzas, their crispy traditional wings—served all day at a great value—bring the perfect balance of spice and tenderness, worthy of pairing with their oven-baked Garlic Bread with Cheese or the indulgent Meatball Melt Garlic Bread. Appetizers like the golden, crunchy Mozzarella Sticks and spicy Cheddar Cheese Hot Poppers add the ideal start to a meal or a satisfying snack on their own.

Dining at South Philly Pizza feels like joining a welcoming neighborhood tradition. The fast, friendly service guarantees your meal arrives fresh and hot, whether you're grabbing a quick bite or settling in to savor every mouthwatering slice. Numerous customers rave about the consistency and quality here. Renee Sanders praises the “crunchy crust with sweet sauce” that delivers bold flavor with every slice, while Jalen Rose, a devoted fan, highlights the perfectly melted cheeses and fast service that make this his go-to pizza spot whenever he visits Ohio.

Beyond the food, South Philly Pizza carries an emotional connection for many, visible in testimonials like Joseph Freetage’s glowing tribute to the “best round” of pizza and wings, and Kristen Boltz’s praise for the exceptional family-friendly vibe. Whether you’re a longtime fan like the Boltz family or a newcomer, the warmth and genuine hospitality feel through in every interaction.

In short, South Philly Pizza is more than just a place to eat — it’s a flavorful journey into classic American pizza craftsmanship, where every bite delivers comfort and satisfaction. For anyone in New Philadelphia looking to indulge in deliciously memorable slices, this gem on Commercial Ave promises a truly satisfying experience that you'll crave long after your last slice.