South Philly Pizza Menu

South Philly Pizza in New Philadelphia, OH, serves up a standout menu built around classic and creative pies. The Pepperoni Pizza with Extra Cheese is a must-try, boasting a crunchy crust and rich, flavorful sauce that has customers like Renee Sanders coming back for more. For those seeking bold tastes, the Buffalo Chicken Pizza variety—with spicy buffalo sauce and tender chicken—delivers a perfect balance of heat and savory goodness. The menu also shines with chicken pizzas dressed in distinct sauces: BBQ, ranch, or garlic butter, each layered with fresh toppings like mushrooms, bacon, and ham, creating depth and variety. Don’t miss their crispy Garlic Cheese Sticks or BBQ Bacon Sticks, which complement the main dishes brilliantly. South Philly Pizza’s attention to quality and taste echoes through every bite, making it a beloved local gem praised for its quick service, generous toppings, and satisfying flavors that linger long after the last slice.